Home Login RADIO ONLINE RSS Facebook
Advertisement

Pirate Radio Operator Challeges FCC Forfeiture Order


Federal Communications Commission
Federal Communications Commission

A North Miami man fined nearly $2.4 million by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) for allegedly operating a pirate radio station is fighting back, filing a formal petition for reconsideration that challenges not only the penalty but also the very authority of the FCC to impose it.

Fabrice Polynice -- also known as DJ Paz -- is asking the Commission to rescind the June 6 Forfeiture Order (FCC 25-32), which penalized him for allegedly operating an unauthorized station, "Radio Touche Douce," on 90.1 MHz for 22 days in early 2023. The FCC has characterized Polynice as a long-term pirate broadcaster dating back to at least 2012.

Polynice, represented by attorney Dan J. Alpert, contends that the fine is not only excessive given his financial situation but also unconstitutional under recent federal court rulings. His petition relies heavily on the 2024 U.S. Supreme Court decision in SEC v. Jarkesy and the 2025 Fifth Circuit ruling in AT&T v. FCC, both of which call into question the legitimacy of federal agencies imposing civil penalties without a trial by jury.

According to financial documents filed by Polynice, his adjusted gross income over the past three years averaged less than $16,000 annually. Despite this, the FCC rejected his request for a reduction, citing a history of unlicensed broadcasting.

Polynice's legal team argues that under Jarkesy, civil penalties such as the one issued by the FCC must be adjudicated in an Article III court, with the right to a jury trial - not through the FCC's internal administrative process. The petition cites language from the Jarkesy ruling stating that imposing such fines without a jury "violates the Seventh Amendment."

"Jarkesy is a game-changer," the filing states, adding that the FCC's forfeiture process, which currently allows the agency to act as prosecutor, judge, and jury, is now on "thinning ice."

The petition also references a white paper by Peter Karanjia, a former FCC deputy general counsel, which concludes that the Commission's traditional "Notice of Apparent Liability to Forfeiture Order" process is likely unconstitutional in light of Jarkesy. Without Congressional action to authorize federal court proceedings for such penalties, Karanjia warns, the FCC's enforcement authority is at risk.

Polynice's filing contends that FCC penalties serve no compensatory function -- funds go directly to the U.S. Treasury -- making them punitive in nature and therefore clearly within the scope of the Seventh Amendment.

Unless the FCC voluntarily revisits its decision, the matter could ultimately end up in federal court, potentially setting precedent for how administrative agencies handle enforcement going forward. The petition formally requests that the Commission reconsider and withdraw its Forfeiture Order.

Advertisement

Latest Radio Stories

Report: Radio Leads All Media in Reach Across Demos
Katz Radio Group
Katz Radio Group
New findings from Nielsen, with added insights from Edison Research's Share of Ear, reaffirm AM/FM radio's position as the leading media platform in the U.S., with unmatched reach and usage across every major demographic -- this according to data, highlighted by Katz Radio Group. More

KSHE 95 Officially Named Missouri's Rock Station
KSHE-FM in St. Louis
KSHE-FM in St. Louis
KSHE 95, the iconic St. Louis-based station, has officially been designated as the State of Missouri's Official Rock Radio Station under newly enacted state legislation, HCS SCS SB 348. The designation, approved by lawmakers on June 24, will take effect statewide on August 28. State Representative Bill More

Black Joins 100.5 The Vibe in Norfolk for Afternoons
Charles Black
Charles Black
Max Media of Hampton Roads taps veteran broadcaster and local radio mainstay Charles Black to join WVBW-FM (100.5 The Vibe)/Norfolk-Virginia Beach as its new afternoon host. Beginning Monday, August 11, he'll air weekdays from 3-7pm. Black brings more than 40 years of experience to The Vibe, with a More
Advertisement

Cumulus Reports Q2 2025 Results Amid Industry Headwinds
Cumulus Media
Cumulus Media
Cumulus Media reported results for the second quarter ended June 30, highlighting both progress in digital revenue initiatives and continued pressure across the broader advertising market. The company posted total net revenue of $186 million for the quarter, down 9.2% from the same period in 2024. Net loss More

2025 NAB Marconi Radio Award Finalists Revealed
Marconi Radio Awards
Marconi Radio Awards
The National Association of Broadcasters (NAB) has announced the finalists for the 2025 NAB Marconi Radio Awards, recognizing excellence in radio across the U.S. The winners will be revealed during a special dinner event at The Edison Ballroom in New York City on October 21, the More

Audacy's Sports WQAM Expands to 104.3 FM in Miami
WAQM-FM in Miami
WAQM-FM in Miami
Audacy is making a major upgrade for Miami Sports outlet WQAM-AM, expanding its coverage to the FM dial at 104.3 FM with a 100,000-watt signal. The move, effective immediately, displaces Alternative WSFS (The Shark) and extends the reach of the station's programming across South Florida while maintaining its More

Return to Menu

Advertisement

Subscribe to our Newsletter
Radio news and headlines delivered right to your e-mail box -- and it's free.

Advertisement

Advertisement