|
|
Supreme Court Sets December 15 Deadline in Nielsen Case
| RADIO ONLINE | Thursday, November 19, 2026 | 2:51pm CT |
|
![]() |
The U.S. Supreme Court has given Cumulus Media until December 15 to respond to Nielsen's petition seeking review of a federal appeals court ruling in their ongoing radio ratings antitrust dispute. The eight-day extension falls short of the additional month Cumulus requested and follows the justices' decision to seek the broadcaster's arguments before determining whether to hear the case.
Cumulus had asked to move its December 7 deadline to January 6, 2027, citing competing legal obligations, including a November 24 oral argument in a separate Nielsen appeal before the Second Circuit. The broadcaster also pointed to scheduled depositions, other litigation and the upcoming holidays.
Nielsen opposed the monthlong extension but agreed to a December 14 deadline. The ratings company argued that a longer delay could prevent the Supreme Court from hearing arguments during its current term. Nielsen also offered to expedite its reply or waive the remaining response period to help move the petition forward.
The Supreme Court granted Cumulus's extension request in part on November 18, setting the new December 15 deadline. The justices have not decided whether to accept Nielsen's case.
Nielsen filed its petition for a writ of certiorari September 15, challenging the Second Circuit's July 13 decision upholding a preliminary injunction issued by U.S. District Judge Jeannette A. Vargas. The injunction prohibits Nielsen from conditioning access to its Nationwide radio ratings product on purchases of local ratings and from using commercially unreasonable standalone pricing to effectively require such purchases.
The dispute arose after Cumulus sought to continue purchasing Nielsen's national ratings for its Westwood One network operations while obtaining local audience measurement from competitor Eastlan in certain markets.
Nielsen argues that the appeals court improperly treated its discounted package of national and local ratings as a potentially unlawful tying arrangement under federal antitrust law. The company contends the decision could have implications beyond broadcasting by exposing common bundled pricing practices to antitrust challenges.
The Supreme Court initially received a waiver from Cumulus declining to respond to Nielsen's petition. However, the justices requested a formal response November 5, giving Cumulus an opportunity to defend the appeals court ruling before the Court considers whether to grant review.
The case has also attracted supporting briefs from the Washington Legal Foundation and a group of antitrust law and economics scholars, both urging the Supreme Court to review the Second Circuit's decision.
Meanwhile, a separate appeal continues over enforcement of the original injunction. Vargas previously ruled that Nielsen's proposed standalone Nationwide pricing remained commercially unreasonable and ordered the company to submit a revised offer or face sanctions of $50,000 per day. The Second Circuit stayed that enforcement order pending appeal, with oral arguments scheduled for November 24.
The Supreme Court petition, docketed as No. 26-370, remains pending. The December 15 response deadline establishes the next step in the proceedings but does not guarantee that the justices will agree to hear Nielsen's challenge.
|
|
Latest Radio Stories
Nielsen Plans One-Minute PPM Qualifier for April 2027
|
FCC Nominee Advances Amid Democratic Boycott
|
Katz: Radio Leads Audio Choices for Holiday Driving
|
|
|
Triton: Podcast Leaders Hold as True Crime Grows
|
Key Networks Renews Partnership With Virtual Jock
|
Keith Vaughn Retires After 26 Years at KYYI
|
|
|




















