Home Login RADIO ONLINE RSS Facebook

FCC Petitions U.S. Supreme Court Over Media Ownership Rules


Federal Communications Commission
Federal Communications Commission

The Solicitor General, on behalf of the FCC and the DOJ, is petitioning the U.S. Supreme Court to review the judgment of the the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit when it vacated the order in the Prometheus Radio Project v. FCC case remanding the Commission's 2018 Incubator Order and its 2017 Order on Reconsideration reinstating the Newspaper/Broadcast Cross-Ownership Rule, Radio/Television Cross-Ownership Rule, Local Television Ownership Rule, Local Radio Ownership Rule and Television Joint Sales Agreement Attribution Rule as they previously existed.

On what's become a rather lengthy fight over media ownership rules, the FCC has battled the Third Circuit following the review of the rules as part of a mandate under the Telecommunications Act. The agency had ruled that new media sources brought about by the Internet, no longer made sense to maintain a ban on a company owning a local newspaper and broadcast station in a single market.

The FCC had sought a rehearing by the full U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit in its decision in the Prometheus Radio Project case. Many broadcasters felt that as a result of the decision, there has been a significant and unnecessary delay in the FCC's consideration of possible changes to its broadcast ownership rules, a process limiting the continued ability of radio outlet to compete with newer digital technologies.

"Here we are again," began an opinion on September 23, 2019 by Circuit Judge Thomas Ambro, who faulted the Commission for failing to adequately explain how the rule change would lead to more female and minority ownership of media outlets.

The FCC, including Chairman Ajit Pai, believes that the Third Circuit has overstepped itself by turning a review of rules meant to ensure healthy competition of viewpoints into a test of what best promotes diversity.

In a cert petition filed on Friday, Solicitor General Noel Francisco said the lower appellate court "flouted bedrock administrative law principles that require judicial deference to agency policy choices, as well as this Court's repeated FCC-specific admonitions that courts must respect the Commission's reasonable judgments about what measures will best serve the public interest."

"The panel's rulings have saddled broadcast markets nationwide with outdated rules that the FCC has repeatedly concluded -- and that the panel has acknowledged -- are preventing struggling traditional outlets from entering transactions that would allow them to retain economic vitality," continued the petition. "The panel's vacaturs have also had the perverse consequence of preventing the agency from studying the effects of its revised ownership rules on women and minorities, thereby gathering the very data the panel insists are necessary for informed rulemaking."

Latest Radio Stories

MediaCo Q3 Revenue Falls 19%, Digital Grows 22%
MediaCo
MediaCo
MediaCo Holding, who acquired Estrella Media's content, network, and digital operations in April 2024, reported third-quarter net revenue of $28.6 million, down 19% from $35.4 million a year earlier. Its net loss narrowed to $9.3 million from $17.9 million, while Adjusted EBITDA More

FCC Clears Draper's $2.5 Million Forever Media Deal
Draper Media
Draper Media
The FCC's Media Bureau has approved Draper Media's $2.5 million acquisition of five full-power radio stations and an FM translator from Forever Media, granting a waiver that will allow Draper to exceed local ownership limits in the Salisbury-Ocean City market. The November 16 decision authorizes the More

Audacy to End Texas State Networks News Programming
Texas State Networks
Texas State Networks
Audacy will discontinue Texas State Networks' news, weather and agricultural programming on January 1, 2027, substantially reducing the statewide radio network's operations while retaining distribution of major sports broadcasts. In a memo to affiliates, Audacy News/Talk Format Vice President and More

Chris Reed Exits KTDY as Position is Eliminated
Chris Reed
Chris Reed
Chris Reed has exited Townsquare Media's AC KTDY (99.9) in Lafayette, LA, where he served as Brand Manager and morning host. Reed said his position was eliminated. Regional Operations Manager Dusty Hayes is now listed as the station's Brand Manager. Reed had co-hosted "Chris & Bernie" with Bernadette Lee More

Triton Finds News Leads Latin America Podcast Listening
Triton Digital
Triton Digital
News accounted for 32% of podcast listening in Latin America during the first eight months of 2026, according to Triton Digital's new LATAM Audio Insights Report. Radio groups also figured prominently in the findings, with Prisa Radio leading both podcast sales networks and streaming More

Alec Medford Joins Houston's Payne & Pendergast
Alec Medford
Alec Medford
Alec Medford is joining Audacy Sports KIKK-FM (95.7 The Fan) in Houston as co-host of "Payne & Pendergast," alongside Seth Payne and Sean Pendergast. He arrives from sister KRLD-FM (105.3 The Fan) in Dallas, where he produced midday show "The K&C Masterpiece." Medford joined KRLD-FM in 2020 and also More

Return to Menu

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement