Home Login RADIO ONLINE RSS Facebook

FCC Commissioner Starks Says NTIA Proposals Are Ill-Advised


Federal Communications Commission
Federal Communications Commission

The National Telecommunications & Information Administration (NTIA) filed a petition for rulemaking related to Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act of 1996, as required by President Trump's Executive Order on Preventing Online Censorship. The petition is meant to jumpstart a rulemaking that would clarify the circumstances under which online platforms, such as asking the FCC to develop regulations that could apply to Facebook, Twitter and others, can become liable for the way they handle user-generated content.

"President Trump is committed to protecting the rights of all Americans to express their views and not face unjustified restrictions or selective censorship from a handful of powerful companies," said Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross in a statement.

In response, FCC Commissioner Geoffrey Starks issued the following statement:

"The rules NTIA has proposed are ill-advised, and the Commission should dispose of this Petition as quickly as possible. As a threshold matter, NTIA has not made the case that Congress gave the FCC any role here. Section 230 is best understood as it has long been understood: as an instruction to courts about when liability should not be imposed.

"The proposed rules themselves are troubling. Among other substantive problems, NTIA seems to have failed to grasp how vast and diverse the ecosystem of interactive computer services is. Every comment section on the Internet would be subject to scrutiny. Imposing intermediary liability on those services-or creating an environment in which those services have an incentive not to moderate content at all-would prove devastating to competition, diversity, and vibrant public spaces online.

"I continue to believe that these rules reflect the President's attempt at retaliation and intimidation-at the very time when social media companies' decisions could impact his own electoral future. This dark cloud over online free speech will cast a lingering shadow on our elections. The FCC should act quickly to end this unfortunate detour and get back to the critical work of closing the digital divide.

"Even if there were a role for the FCC, adopting these rules now would be a terrible idea. Congress laid out Section 230's original scope, and Congress should decide whether to change it. In fact, members are already actively considering reform."

FCC Commissioner Jessica Rosenworcel said in a statement, "The FCC shouldn't take this bait. While social media can be frustrating, turning this agency into the President's speech police is not the answer. If we honor the Constitution, we will reject this petition immediately."

Latest Radio Stories

RAB Plans AI Workshop for Radio Sales Teams
Radio Advertising Bureau (RAB)
Radio Advertising Bureau (RAB)
RAB will present "The AI Advantage for Radio Sales" at noon CT on Wednesday, December 2, offering broadcasters practical ways to use artificial intelligence for prospecting, creative development and client presentations. Sponsored by Spotwise.ai, the live session will feature RAB Senior Vice President of More

Nielsen Plans One-Minute PPM Qualifier for April 2027
Nielsen
Nielsen
Nielsen plans to introduce a one-minute listening qualifier for its Audio Portable People Meter measurement beginning with the April 2027 survey, reducing the threshold used to credit Average Quarter-Hour listening. The change follows Nielsen's January 2025 move from a More

Pierre Bouvard Exits Westwood One After 11 Years
Pierre Bouvard
Pierre Bouvard
Pierre Bouvard has departed as Chief Insights Officer of Cumulus Media's Westwood One Audio Active Group, ending an 11-year tenure with the company. He announced his exit Thursday in a LinkedIn post, saying the research and advisory team remains intact. "Looking back on my 11 years there, what stands out More

FCC Nominee Advances Amid Democratic Boycott
Danielle Thumann Severs
Danielle Thumann Severs
The Senate Commerce Committee voted 15-0 Wednesday to advance Danielle Thumann Severs' nomination to the Federal Communications Commission, sending it to the full Senate despite a Democratic boycott over the agency's political balance and questions about her work on broadcast matters. Thumann Severs, a More

Katz: Radio Leads Audio Choices for Holiday Driving
Katz Radio Group
Katz Radio Group
AM/FM radio is the leading audio choice for holiday road trips and errands among consumers surveyed by Katz Analytics, according to a new Katz Radio Group blog post examining seasonal travel, shopping and advertising habits. The November survey of 600 consumers found that 83% of More

Supreme Court Sets December 15 Deadline in Nielsen Case
Cumulus Media & Nielsen
Cumulus Media & Nielsen
The U.S. Supreme Court has given Cumulus Media until December 15 to respond to Nielsen's petition seeking review of a federal appeals court ruling in their ongoing radio ratings antitrust dispute. The eight-day extension falls short of the additional month Cumulus requested and follows the justices' decision More

Return to Menu

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement